While browsing the internet, I came across a headline (I read the article, I didn’t stop at the headline) saying something along the lines of: not everyone has liked the Javis’ latest work, La Bola Negra, following a negative review from a critic at The New Yorker. Although the article weaves comments from the critic, Justin Chang, with praise for the film (they mention he has a Pulitzer, so at least we’re not being criticized by a nobody), it struck me that it wasn’t the only article I could find that mentioned the bad review from the New York outlet.
While I wondered at what point it became relevant news that a critic (but one with a Pulitzer, mind you) has an opinion different from that of the vast majority, I remembered director Taika Waititi’s recent outburst after the terrible reception of his film Klara and the Sun.
Amid the echoes of the flop he suffered after its US release, which have reverberated all the way to the cancellation of its release in Spain, Waititi has opted for the reliable diplomatic route offered by social media to give his version of events. Or rather, to get things off his chest.
In a post in which, after saying he hasn’t read reviews in almost 15 years (but does listen to people. I don’t know which people, Taika, but carry on, don’t worry), he adds that critics are poor lost souls who have settled for their jobs because they failed to achieve their dreams of becoming artists. Along with assorted emojis (which I’ve always thought lend seriousness and gravitas to any statement), he ends by adding that the critics attacking his latest creation are the same ones who hated Jojo Rabbit.

Setting aside the fact that this claim is untrue, since that film (in which Waititi frolicked like a sprightly child at a village fair, playing a famous Austrian painter) was received infinitely better by both critics and audiences, and earned him an Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay, it seems someone has gotten upset.
[FIST EMOJI] [EXPLOSION EMOJI] [CRYING FACE EMOJI]
Everything okay at home, Taika?
We all like our achievements to be recognized. We want to feel happy when we do something well and to be told “Good job,” and if it comes with a pat on the back, even better. But being recognized is just as necessary as knowing how to accept it when the applause turns to boos. You must have done something wrong.
Obviously, critics are in no way the champions of reason, the only ones capable of guiding, inspiring and instructing the masses. Everyone makes mistakes, and critics are no exception. Films like The Shining, The Thing, Possession or Vertigo were received negatively upon release, and only with time have they reached the status they enjoy today.
I doubt Klara and the Sun will follow that path, but I could be wrong, of course.
The main problem, beyond poor Taika’s bruised ego, lies in pointing to critics as the main culprits for a film’s failure when it doesn’t get the reception that was expected (something similar, but with fewer emojis, has happened with Digger).
It may be a clash of egos, it may be a mere tantrum against an obvious target, it may be something typical of stars, but… how much is a star worth? Which has more value, the stars that appear on screen or the 2½ that appear at the top of the reviews? And while we’re at it… why do we keep reading reviews with stars, percentages or little numbers saying that this film is better than that one by 1.5 points?
The answer to my question probably lies in the fact that, through stars, points, or percentages (or ripe or rotten tomatoes), anyone can obtain, in an obvious and easy-to-understand way, the knowledge of whether a film is good or bad, better or worse.
What lies behind that rating is the difficulty of evaluating a work, the ability to place it within a canon, to discern the intention of everyone who contributed to its creation. And more things, but if I go on any longer I’ll end up using emojis.
We’ve grown used to quick reviews, glued to the release (or pre-release), to press embargoes, to advance screenings with so-called cinephile influencers who will post their positive opinions following the patterns of both social media (SEO, character counts, eye-catching titles) and the distributors (don’t say anything about our lead actress having so much Botox that she looks like a different person, don’t say our actor looks like he was in a sword-and-sandal epic instead of a Marvel film, don’t say the director-for-hire merely signed the film and posed in set photos pointing this way and that).
I don’t think critics have the power to destroy anyone’s career (right, Michael Bay?). I do think that, by voicing their opinions, they expose themselves to becoming targets of filmmakers’ wrath, since if a film flops at the box office, it’s easier to blame those sad souls (Hey, Taika 😉) than the members of the audience whose attention spans are being crushed by the very social networks on which directors vent. They prefer to stay at home, comfortable in their armchairs. Phone in hand. Netflix in the background.
The democratization of opinion and the influence of the masses has perhaps gotten a little out of hand. Now we all have access to platforms (like Rotten Tomatoes or Letterboxd, the latter of which may be bought by the New York Times for around 300 million euros) where we can share our likes, dislikes and opinions. And if your opinion doesn’t match mine, I attack you with a post in which I disable the comments (like Taika, who’s had enough already, poor man) and walk away feeling smug. I honestly prefer to think before giving an opinion, to sit down and mull over what’s going through my head before saying whether a film is good or bad.

After watching the aforementioned Digger, I didn’t walk out of the theater declaring it either a marvel or a monstrosity. Given how polarizing its nature is, forming an opinion before reaching the cinema parking lot was going to be a pretty tall order, so I gave up on the idea. Things need time.
And finally… what’s all this about judging a film’s quality by counting the minutes of ovation it receives at the festival of the moment? If I ever conceive a film one day (that is, I’ll write it, direct it, produce it, star in it, compose the soundtrack, and even be my own butt double… because I have an ego too), at 30 seconds of applause I’ll send everyone home and head to the hotel bar for a beer to celebrate.
You must be logged in to post a comment.